Top 5 Best Flea Collars For Your Cat (**2021 Review**)

Looking for the best flea collars for cats? We've got you covered!

In this Pest Strategies product review you can expect to learn:

  • Our #1 overall flea collar (and our favorite budget friendly collar)
  • Some of the dangers of fleas on your cat
  • How flea collars work with cats
  • If flea collars even effective (and safe)
  • Critical cat flea removal tips
  • And the top 5 cat collars we looked at to help with fleas for this review
best flea collar for cats
psfs-item__image
Bayer Seresto Collar
The broad insecticides imidacloprid and flumethrin kill current fleas within 24 hours and kill any new fleas who try to jump on within 2 hours.
FEATURES
  • Very easy to use and put on
  • Comparable to "spot on" treatments
  • Brand name collar

Ready to save your cat from flea madness? Keep on reading!

ImageProduct
pest-table__image
Bayer Seresto Collar
  • Very easy to use and put on
  • Comparable to "spot on" treatments
  • Brand name collar
  • Very easy to use and put on
  • Comparable to "spot on" treatments
  • Brand name collar
View on Amazon
pest-table__image
Primova Flea And Tick Collar For Cats
  • Lasts up to 8 months
  • 100% natural
  • Flea comb included
  • Lasts up to 8 months
  • 100% natural
  • Flea comb included
View on Amazon
pest-table__image
Shengkou Natural Flea And Tick Collar For Cats
  • Safe and effective
  • Adjustable
  • Lasts an entire year
  • Safe and effective
  • Adjustable
  • Lasts an entire year
View on Amazon
pest-table__image
Sobaken Natural Flea Collar For Cats
  • Lasts 8 months
  • Safe and effective
  • Pleasant odor
  • Lasts 8 months
  • Safe and effective
  • Pleasant odor
View on Amazon
pest-table__image
Hartz Ultraguard Flea and Tick Collar For Cats
  • Provides 7 months of flea killing protection
  • Infused with an effective flea killing pesticide
  • Safe if applied correctly
  • Provides 7 months of flea killing protection
  • Infused with an effective flea killing pesticide
  • Safe if applied correctly
View on Amazon

Our Overall #1 Rated Pick

Updated as of April 9th, 2021

  • Auto release collar to prevent choking
  • No vials, no drops, and no wet messy cat
  • Collar lasts 8 months for continued protection

Bayer's flea collar is one of the main reasons flea collars are making a comeback. 

The broad insecticides imidacloprid and flumethrin kill current fleas within 24 hours and kill any new fleas who try to jump on within 2 hours.

We like it because it is simple - no vials, no drops, and no wet messy blobs of fur on my cat. It lasts 8 months and has a auto release to prevent choking.

A little expensive but definitely worth it for your cat.

Also as a public service announcement.

There are SO many knockoff "natural" essential oil based collars popping up. Most of them are run by non-experts looking to sell cheap collars that have little or no effect on your cat's fleas. If you look closely at the reviews of these products they are mostly fake and/or for completely different products!

Below is a screenshot from poor people who bought a terrible knockoff cat flea collar that did not work. Check it out!

cat flea collar review problems

Even more frightening is that some cats are EXTREMELY sensitive to essential oils as they lack the proper enzymes in their liver to breakdown when the chemicals as they're absorbed into their skin.

Don't buy those unless you're on a REALLY tight budget and you have no other option.

Seresto is a reputable brand that we can stand behind that DOES NOT use essential oils. The rest of the companies we keep seeing popup are constantly getting negative reviews and bad feedback from their customers.

AVOID them, please and go with Bayer's Seresto Collar.

Want to learn more about correct collar usage and about cat flea removal Keep reading!

ribbin-img
Terminix-logo

Rating: 97.50

Our #1 Ranked For: Termites,Bed Bugs, and Larger Infestations

aptive-logo

Rating: 97.00

Our #1 Ranked For: Ants, Roaches, Spiders, and Rodents Issues

Orkin-Logo

Rating: 95.70

Our #1 Ranked For: Mosquito Removal, Fleas, Ticks, Wasps, And Other Stinging Insects

Top 5 Best Cat Flea Collars

Short on time? Check out below our top flea collar for cats. Continue reading if you want to learn more!

We all know how difficult it can be to give a cat a bath...

We endure multiple escape attempts, flying water bombs, and the wrath of claws and teeth.

Bad stuff.

Bathing your cat regularly is one of the most recommended tips to get rid of fleas.

Unfortunately, it isn’t always practical or possible for me and my water-hating cat. A few cat owners are lucky to have cats who love water, and to them we say, “No fair!” for we have had to turn to other, more aggressive flea control methods.

Enter cat flea collars.

Flea collars were once the top choice to when dealing with cats with fleas, until the development of more powerful topical “spot-on” drop treatments.

Some owners continue to use collars due to their lower cost, or for cats who have allergies or reactions to topical spot-on products. New formulations of flea collars are proving to be just as effective as other treatments and their popularity is growing.

That being said... let's get into how to go about buying these collars.

If you want to know about how to get rid of fleas overall, check out our other guide here.

Dangers of fleas on cats?

No one likes to see their cat suffering with fleas. The constant biting and scratching is unnerving for anyone.

Not only are fleas an annoyance, your cat is at risk for serious health issues when these pests take control.

Fleas are ectoparasites, which means they bite and feed off the blood of their host. If you don’t take the necessary action, your cat can get diseases and parasites such as anemia, tapeworms, cat flu, and flea allergy dermatitis.

Read Also: How long do fleas live?

We recommend checking for fleas on your cat on a regular basis so you can stop major outbreaks before they take hold. Cats are excellent groomers and may be able to hide the problem well. You should use a flea comb on your cat’s fur, check for dead fleas in bath water, and pay attention to behavior changes such as excessive licking or biting.

Adult fleas leave behind small specs of dark-colored digested blood. Brush your cat over a white towel or large piece of paper to look for this “flea dirt.” Still unsure? If you add water to the specs, you will notice they turn red.

It is important that you act quickly once you notice a flea problem on your cat. Flea collars may be a good, relatively low maintenance option for you to treat fleas on your cat, depending on the severity of your flea problem.

Read Also: How do you know if your cat has fleas?

Want To Solve Your Pest Problem Now?


We’ve partnered with Terminix to bring you exclusive discounts and priority service for your pest control needs. Click to get your free instant price quote.

Limited Time: Save $50 off your pest control service.

How do collars work for cats with fleas?

Designs

The designs of collars vary depending on the formulation of the insecticide used. There are two primary types – solid and liquid.

  • Solid: For the solid type, solid insecticide and resin are mixed so that as the collar wears away from rubbing against your cat’s skin and fur, the insecticide releases over time. Depending on the specific insecticide used, it either disperses across your cat’s skin or absorbs into the top layers. For the dispersion type, the flea only needs to contact the insecticide for it to take effect. For the absorption type, the flea needs to bite the skin.
  • Liquid: The liquid insecticide preparation releases as a gas. These are most effective for repelling fleas, but not killing them.

Insecticides on Flea Collars

Some ingredients, called adulticides, only kill adult fleas. Two examples are imidacloprid and fipronil. Insect Growth Regulators (IGRs) are hormones that render adult fleas, eggs, and larvae sterile so they can’t reproduce.

Two examples of IGRs are pyriproxyfen and S-methoprene. They successfully end the life cycle of the fleas and help to control them over time.

How effective are flea collars for cats?

Some products combine adulticides with an IGR to reap the benefits of both – quick relief for your cat from bites and a way to avoid the spread of new fleas. A few flea collars can kill adults within 24 hours and last up to 8 months making them comparable to liquid drop treatments without the mess.

One thing that can reduce a collar’s efficacy is getting it wet multiple times per week. Most collars are listed as “waterproof” so a monthly bath should be ok, but too many and the insecticide could wear off. If your cat plays in water, you may want to take the collar off, put it in a plastic bag, and replace it once your cat is dry again.

The effectiveness of a flea collar is limited to your cat – not the eggs, larvae, and pupae in your carpet or in cracks of your wooden floor. IGRs can help some, but it will take a while for those take effect.

The fleas you see on your cat only account for a small amount of the overall infestation. An adult female flea lays about 50 eggs each day and most of these fall to the ground. Adult fleas represent just 5% of your overall flea population. Another 50% are eggs, 35% are larvae, and 10% are pupae. To eliminate your flea problem completely, you need to focus on treating your home environment as well.

How to get rid of cat fleas in you house?

No matter which type of flea collar you choose to use for your cat, it is critical that you use Integrated Pest Management (IPM) tactics to eliminate fleas. IPM promotes the use of a variety of approaches to kill or sterilize the fleas and eggs on your cat, in your home, in your yard, and on items such as pet bedding and linens.

Using IPM requires a thorough understanding of the cat flea life cycle so you know which products to use in different areas. Pay close attention to the labels of products to determine if they work on killing adults, eggs, larvae, and pupae. Products that say “Repels fleas” will most likely not be effective in removing fleas you already have.

Be careful to not combine too many products on your cat or in areas where they live as too many chemicals can be toxic. Check with your veterinarian to determine the best approach for your situation.

Vacuuming is one of the most advised techniques you can use to stop the spread of fleas. When larvae hatch, they eat eggs and flea dirt.

Vacuuming at least once per day may help to reduce their food source so they won’t survive. You should also vacuum before you do any home treatments such as spraying or using a fogger.

Vibrations and heat can cause pupae to hatch, which would leave them more vulnerable to the effects of the chemicals.

Be sure to empty out the canister or bag away from your home so the fleas don’t jump out. Some people even put cut up pieces of flea collars in their canisters to kill the fleas they catch.

Want To Solve Your Pest Problem Now?


We’ve partnered with Terminix to bring you exclusive discounts and priority service for your pest control needs. Click to get your free instant price quote.

Limited Time: Save $50 off your pest control service.

Are Flea collars safe for cats and humans?

Flea collars are generally considered safe for cats and humans, but you should take some precautions. Most flea collar labels clearly state “Do Not Allow Children to Play with Collar.” Some insecticides are more toxic to humans than others. If you handle a collar, you should wash your hands.

You don’t need to be concerned with petting your cat while they are wearing a collar, just wash your hands after. Even if you were to ingest some of the insecticide, it would take a much larger amount to do any harm. To be on the safe side, just use some common sense.

As with any product, even those considered safe, some cats will experience a negative reaction. If your cat has hair loss, sores, or redness around the neck, discontinue use and consult your veterinarian.

There may be some discomfort in the first few hours as the fleas go through the dying process. Unfortunately, the fleas can still bite for a short time while the chemicals take effect.

Another concern with collars is the possibility of strangulation. Make sure you select a collar with a safety release mechanism that opens once the pressure goes over the limit.

Cat Collars For Fleas Products Reviewed

Using flea collars can be a good strategy for getting rid of fleas on cats. Here are a few of the top choices available on the market right now.

  • Very easy to use and put on
  • Comparable to "spot on" treatments
  • Brand name collar

This product is one of the main reasons flea collars are making a comeback.

The broad insecticides imidacloprid and flumethrin kill current fleas within 24 hours and kill any new fleas who try to jump on within 2 hours.

We like it because it is simple - no vials, no drops, and no wet messy blobs of fur on your cat.

Other collars tend to lean on essential oils, which can be toxic to some cats in the wrong doses.

Pros

  • Very easy to use- just size the collar, put it on, and you're good to go
  • Slow release of chemicals allows the collar to last up to 8 months
  • Quick release safety latch to prevent choking
  • Not oily or greasy
  • Comparable to "spot on" treatments

Cons

  • Not an all-natural option
  • Some may find this collar to be expensive
  • Lasts up to 8 months
  • 100% natural
  • Flea comb included

Most cats have sensitive skin which requires a degree of caution when using flea collars with chemicals to ensure safety. This flea collar is packed with 5 different essential oils that actively repel fleas and their larvae and eggs. 

The essential oils release slowly throughout the day to establish a thin but firm coat along with the upper layer of skin. The collar remains active for up to 8 months and is waterproof. 

As an added bonus, this collar also comes with a flea comb, which can be run along the coat of your cat to remove dormant eggs or fleas that may be hiding on fur that isn’t coated with the oils. 

Going natural may only repel the fleas, but this is sometimes the best option to take to prevent painful skin irritations on your cat. 

Pros

  • Lasts up to 8 months
  • 100% natural
  • Flea comb included
  • Provides protection 24/7

Cons

  • The collar does not kill fleas or eggs
  • Some users report problems adjusting the collar
  • Safe and effective
  • Adjustable
  • Lasts an entire year

Fleas are highly sensitive to essential oils, and this is what makes natural-based flea collars an effective alternative for cats. This product contains 5 different essential oils that repel fleas once they jump onto your cat. 

Essential oils give off a strong scent, but Shengkou specifically formulated the dominant scent to be citronella, which is a bit more pleasant in the long run. Speaking of time, this collar lasts a full year once you place it around your feline’s neck. Fleas, their eggs and larvae, and other parasites like ticks are actively repelled for a full-year. 

The collar is built to be used by any size cat, and the collar is adjustable based on the behavior of your cat. The waterproof design also protects the oils from degrading due to excessive moisture build-up that can occur in moist environments. 

The essential oils are time-released and provide just enough coat coverage to keep parasites from nesting deep into your cat’s fur. 

Pros

  • Safe and effective
  • Adjustable
  • Lasts an entire year
  • Repels both fleas and ticks

Cons

  • Essential oils may cause allergic reactions in some cats
  • The oils may congeal into a white powder
  • Lasts 8 months
  • Safe and effective
  • Pleasant odor

This flea collar by Sobaken prioritizes skin safety for your cat by also using natural ingredients and by making the collar easily adjustable. Cats can easily find ways to remove flea collars due to discomfort, but this product is comfortable enough not to cause skin irritation. 

Like the previous two collars, this collar also uses essential oils that last 8 months to repel fleas and eggs. The standout feature of this collar is the lack of congealing residue build-up that other natural flea collars can cause. 

Simply adjust the collar to your cat’s neck and start providing up to 8 months of flea prevention on your feline.

Pros

  • Lasts 8 months
  • Safe and effective
  • Pleasant odor
  • Adjustable collar

Cons

  • Does not kill fleas
  • Provides 7 months of flea killing protection
  • Infused with an effective flea killing pesticide
  • Safe if applied correctly

Natural flea collars are great for cats with sensitive skin, but they only repel fleas; they do not kill them. If you live in an area with large flea populations, you may find that chemical flea collars work best.

This collar uses a chemical called tetrachlorvinphos, which is approved by the EPA to be used in flea collars for pets. This chemical attacks the central nervous system of pests and can also destroy flea eggs. 

The collar is adjustable to your cat’s neck and the chemical provides protection to the cat’s coat for up to 7 months. If your cat ever gets irritated by the collar, it also features a safety feature where the collar can be easily snapped off. 

When all else fails, chemical collars are the best option and this collar gets the flea-killing job done. 

Pros

  • Provides 7 months of flea killing protection
  • Infused with an effective flea killing pesticide
  • Safe if applied correctly
  • Kills all life stages of fleas and ticks

Cons

  • Can cause skin irritation
  • May cause allergic reactions

Our Top Pick: Bayer Seresto Cat Collar

While there are several products available that are effective in killing fleas on cats, Bayer Seresto's collar is our top pick for a flea collar and may be my top pick of any topical product.

The choice between spot-on treatment or the Bayer Seresto collar comes down to personal preference, and is not so much based on which one is more effective anymore.

Bayer may be the better option for cats who don’t tolerate drops well, or who spend too much time trying to lick the solution. The Bayer collar has brought flea collars back into the mix as a strong option for quick flea elimination and long-term flea control.

Alternatively, we recommend getting a free quote from one of our top ranked exterminators. You enter in your location details and get a couple free quotes to knock our your problem quickly. 

Fleas aren't something to mess around with.

If you feel the least bit uncomfortable handling pesticides and/or other chemicals around your pets, our recommendation is to use the tool, find a couple exterminators (they're all pre-qualified) and ask them your questions.

Other Cat Product Reviews

Curious about other cat related products? Check out our other detailed guides to help you deal with your pest problems.

Fleas are a very irritating problem for both the cat and its owner! Despite their minute size, fleas are more[...]
Looking for a detailed review of advantage II for your cat...?...well than you're in the right place.If your cat starts[...]
Looking for the best cat flea shampoos?You're in the right spot!In this guide you can expect to learn:The typical cost[...]
Looking for the best flea treatment for your cat? Well, you're in the right place! In this Pest Strategies guide[...]

Get Your Free Quote In Seconds

Because pest control products can be dangerous to your family if mishandled, we always recommend consulting with an exterminator even if just to ask for advice on how to apply pest control products yourself.

Our pest experts review each company for quality, cost, customer service, safety, and 100’s of other important factors and assess a rating out of 100. Below are our top 3 picks based on that review for pest removal. We’ve set up a direct line with each company so you can get fast free quotes right now.

ribbin-img
Terminix-logo

Rating: 97.50

Our #1 Ranked For: Termites,Bed Bugs, and Larger Infestations

aptive-logo

Rating: 97.00

Our #1 Ranked For: Ants, Roaches, Spiders, and Rodents Issues

Orkin-Logo

Rating: 95.70

Our #1 Ranked For: Mosquito Removal, Fleas, Ticks, Wasps, And Other Stinging Insects

3 thoughts on “Top 5 Best Flea Collars For Your Cat (**2021 Review**)”

  1. Alternative to Seresto . I need 5 cat flea collars that contain 10% flumethrin and 4,5 % midaceoprid. Seresto is too much money for me as I am on soc sec.

    Reply
  2. I have used the Hartz flea collars for years. Reading the negative comments(seizures, death) about side effects, I am worried. I also have 5 cats. Cost is a problem. Why do these things have to be so expensive??

    Reply
    • When it comes to any flea drop or collar, every pet will react differently.

      It’s hard for anyone to be able to accurately predict what will happen to your pets come into contact with the chemicals.

      The best advice I can offer is to try one collar and keep a close watch on your pets until you know if they are having a reaction or not.

      As always, consult with your Vet before giving them anything!

      Reply

Leave a Comment