Top 5 Best Slug (and Snail) Killers (2021 Review)

Affiliate disclosure

In order to help pay for the cost of running this website we are an affiliate of many brands and products we review and promote.

What this means is that if you purchase a product by clicking on a link or image on this website, we may earn a small affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. You can think of this is like a referral fee.

One affiliate partner we use is Amazon.com. We are also partnered with Networx.com, which helps people find certified pest control operators for their pest problems.

All products promoted on this website have been vetted and are our actual recommendations. If there is a case brought to our attention by our readers or our own internal staff whereby a product no longer meets our expectations we remove it. Of course, opinions differ and what we believe to the be best . may be different from what you to believe to be the best. In such cases, let us know by contacting us here so we can review in detail.

PestStrategies.com (as operated by LTV Commerce LLC) is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, amazon.ca, amazon.uk.

Home > Product Reviews > Weed Products > Top 5 Best Slug (and Snail) Killers (2021 Review)

If you’ve got slugs and snails feeding on your crops, ornamentals, or flowers, the damage will begin showing up very quickly.

They will shred leaves, leaving behind ragged holes or just the ‘ribs’ and will bore circular holes in underground crops.

They can lay 30 eggs at a time so as soon as you suspect you have a slug and snail infestation, you need to figure out how to get rid of them right away.

We’re going to explain what slug bait is so you can use it to eliminate them, along with what is in it, how to use it, and what to expect when you do.

We’ll also explain the differences between slugs and snails.

Reviewed By:
Ed Spicer

Ed has been working in the pest control industry for years helping 1,000's of homeowners navigate the world of insect and rodent management. He manages Pest Strategies now helping homeowners around the world!

Best Overall
Overall Rating
4.8
Best Service
Overall Rating
4

Sluggo Wildlife and Pet Safe Slug Killer

Features
  • The active ingredient is iron phosphate
  • Two-in-one bait and killer
  • OMRI-listed

Garden Safe Slug & Snail Bait

Features
  • The active ingredient is iron phosphate
  • Popular slug and snail bait
  • OMRI-listed

Ortho Bug-Geta Snail and Slug Killer

Features
  • The active ingredient is Sulfur
  • Ortho is a well-known brand name
  • Not OMRI-listed

Corry’s Slug & Snail Killer

Features
  • The active ingredient is 5% sodium ferric EDTA
  • It is not OMRI-listed
  • No limits around edible crops

Southern Ag Snail and Slug Bait

Features
  • The active ingredient is 3.25% Metaldehyde
  • Extremely toxic to children and pets
  • Best used for commercial operations

Table Of Contents

    What Are Slug (and Snail) Killers?

    Any chemical intended to kill slugs and snails is called a molluscicide to differentiate them from pesticides. Most pesticides aren’t effective on slugs and snails so separate chemicals had to be developed specifically for them.

    They’re a bait that slugs and snails are drawn or attracted to. They eat it and get the poison. They soon stop eating and within a few days, it kills them.

    Some baits have extra ingredients added to them to increase their attractiveness to slugs and snails.

    Depending on the active ingredient in the bait, it could take from three to seven days to kill a slug or snail once they’ve eaten the bait.

    While they are dying, they’ll return to their hiding places so you won’t necessarily find their dead bodies or shells.

     

    Slugs vs. Snails

    Slugs and snails are both mollusks (phylum Mollusca) in the class known as Gastropoda. They are close relatives. The main difference between them is that slugs don’t have shells and snails do.

    During times of low humidity or temperature extremes, snails can retreat into their shell and seal the opening using a thin layer of hardened mucus and calcium that is called an epiphragm.

    Because they don’t have a protective shell, slugs prefer to spend more time underground than snails do. This makes them extremely destructive toward root crops of all kinds, buried seeds, and seedlings.

    Snails and slugs share the same diet, require the same environmental conditions, and have the same reaction to baits. As a result of their close relationship, any bait that will kill slugs will also kill snails and vice versa.

     

    How Do Slug (and Snail) Killers Work?

    Each active ingredient has a different mode of action. We’ll look at each one in turn.

    • Metaldehyde is one that works primarily in the stomach, producing its toxic effects after it has been ingested. For humans, it is highly toxic in gaseous form, “mildly” toxic when it is ingested, and slightly toxic to the touch.
    • Iron Phosphate is a stomach poison for slugs and snails. It causes damage to the tissue in their digestive tract. They stop eating and soon die but the exact mode of action still isn’t clear. For humans, iron phosphate is considered very low toxicity when eaten.
    • Sulfur is present in most of the food we eat but for insects and mollusks, it creates problems in the stomach, digestive tract, and lungs. It also creates neurological problems leading to brain cell death. The exact mode of action is still poorly understood.
    • Ferric Sodium EDTA works in much the same way as iron phosphate, only faster. Because it works faster, less of it is required to kill slugs and snails. It is also somewhat more toxic to people than iron phosphate.
    Compare Pest Control Companies Near You

    Are Slug (and Snail) Killers Effective For Killing Slugs and Snails?

    They are very effective. Most of the active ingredients used in slug baits will kill the slugs and snails within a week. Some will kill them in only three days.

    However, not all of them withstand heavy rain very well and will have to be reapplied frequently.

    How To Use Slug (and Snail) Killers

    Slugs and snails are most often active during periods of warmth and high humidity or rain. They prefer their food in the same condition, therefore the best time to distribute the bait is in the evening around sunset.

    This prevents the sun from drying the bait and making it unpalatable to them. The baits should be broadcast as evenly as possible.

    Don’t let them clump up in piles. Moisture can become trapped in the piles and the bait will get moldy.

    Most of the baits should be kept off the plants you’re protecting. After spreading the bait, go back and briefly shake the plants to knock any pellets off them.

    Check the bait after you water your lawn or garden and after each heavy rain. Some of them, such as sulfur-based baits will be washed away and you’ll have to reapply them.

    Others, such as metaldehyde and iron phosphate-based baits will withstand the rain.

    Are Slug (and Snail) Killers Safe Around My Pets and Children?

    Baits that use metaldehyde as the active ingredient are not safe around pets or children and should be restricted to those areas pets and children don’t have access to.

    Greenhouses are a good example of a safe place to use metaldehyde-based baits.

    The other active ingredients are generally regarded as safe around pets and children.

    How Do You Find the Best Slug (and Snail) Killer?

    1. The first thing you should look for is a bait that is safe around children and pets. Safety should always come first.
    2. Slug baits have to be used outside and heavy rains often wash away or dissolve them. Look for baits that can withstand several heavy rains. This reduces how many times you’ll have to reapply them.
    3. Some baits are bright white, which makes them stand out like a sore thumb on your lawn or garden. From an aesthetic point of view, dark-colored granules or pellets are preferred.

    Final Thoughts On Slug (and Snail) Killers

    Older snail baits containing metaldehyde still work but the high toxicity levels make them dangerous. We included one of them for those who want it, but the new iron phosphate baits work almost as fast and are as close to 100% safe as anything can be.

    Give the Sluggo Wildlife and Pet Safe Slug Killer a try and you’ll be killing snails and slugs before you know it.

    Related Articles

    Sluggo Wildlife and Pet Safe Slug Killer

    Sluggo is one of the best slug and snail baits available. The active ingredient is iron phosphate, so it’s safe around pets and children.

    It comes in a granular form that is easy to apply and spread. It’s a two-in-one bait that attracts and kills slugs and snails.

    It is still effective after it rains or you water the lawn or garden. It is OMRI-listed, so it’s safe for organic farming and it begins killing slug and snails within three to six days.

    It’s also extremely popular with consumers. However, it won’t kill anything except slugs and snails.

    The Good And The Bad

    • Safe around pets and children
    • Unaffected by rain or watering
    • Won’t kill anything except snails and slugs
    Overall Rating
    4.8

    Garden Safe Slug & Snail Bait

    This bait uses iron phosphate as the active ingredient, plus other additives that make it attractive to slugs and snails.

    Scatter the pellets around the lawn or garden where slugs and snails are fond of feeding. They’ll eat it and die within a few days to a week.

    It’s safe around pets and children, OMRI-listed for organic farming, and kills snails and slugs within three to six days. It should be put out in the evening just before they begin coming out to feed.

    However, it won’t kill anything except snails and slugs.

    The Good And The Bad

    • Safe around pets and children
    • Kills slugs and snail within three to six days
    • Kills only snails and slugs

    Ortho Bug-Geta Snail and Slug Killer

    The active ingredient in Ortho Bug-Geta Snail and Slug Killer is sulfur. It remains effective for up to three weeks after it has been applied to your lawn, garden, or in your greenhouse.

    It’s easy to apply; there’s no mixing or spraying required.

    It is safe around children, pets, and wildlife but the white pellets really draw attention to themselves in the garden, detracting from the aesthetics of your lawn, flowerbeds, or garden.

    Watering the yard or garden, or steady rain, will dissolve the pellets and you’ll need to reapply them. It kills slugs and snails, but not as fast or effectively as iron phosphate-based baits.

    The Good And The Bad

    • Easy to apply
    • Lasts for three weeks
    • Safe around children and pets
    • Dissolves after rain or watering
    • White pellets aren’t aesthetic
    • Slow killing snails and slugs

    Corry's Slug & Snail Killer

    The active ingredient is 5% sodium ferric EDTA. The EDTA makes the ferric (iron) work faster than iron phosphate, killing slugs and snails in three days instead of three to seven.

    It’s still safe for children, pets, and wildlife.

    It’s not OMRI-listed but it can still be used around the turf, ornamentals, vegetables, fruit, and other edible crops.

    It will remain effective for about two weeks before you need to spread more. It also has to be replaced and reapplied after a heavy rain.

    The Good And The Bad

    • It is safe around pets and children
    • Works faster than iron phosphate
    • Effective for up to two weeks at a time
    • Don’t put it directly on crops

    Southern Ag Snail and Slug Bait

    The active ingredient is 3.25% Metaldehyde, one of the best active ingredients on the market today. It is also highly toxic to children, pets, and wildlife.

    It should never be used where any of them have access to it.

    Due to its high toxicity, it only requires one pound of the pelletized bait to treat up to 1500 square feet. It kills slugs and snails very quickly, won’t wash away in heavy rains, and is an excellent choice for commercial operations or inside greenhouses.

    It’s not OMRI-listed for organic farming but is suitable for any other kind of farming, just so long as you’re very careful when using it.

    The Good And The Bad

    • Works faster than any other bait
    • Won’t wash away in multiple heavy rains
    • Pelletized bait is easy to apply
    • One pound will cover up to 1500 square feet
    • Requires extra caution when using it
    Compare Pest Control Companies Near You