Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Pest Control Companies in Islip, NY

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

Islip is home to 340 thousand people and, much to our dismay, an untold number of pests. Homeowners who have a routine pest control plan can avoid encounters with these unwelcome creatures. Fortunately, pest control companies can help you with this problem.

There are many exterminators to choose from, which can make hard for homeowners to know which is best for them. That’s why we've analyzed plenty of options to find the best pest control companies in Islip. Keep reading to learn more about each exterminator.

Our Recommended Providers

Top Pick
4.8/5
  • Covers 13 common pests in general plan
  • Offers wildlife removal
  • Extra treatments as needed at no extra cost
Comprehensive Service
4.7/5
  • Pest control guarantee
  • Treats over 15 common pests
  • Offers instant online quotes

Top 10 Best Pest Control Companies in Islip

Terminix

Terminix Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
200 13th Ave #1a, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 (631) 468-4917 terminix.com

Free inspections

Educational web content

Reviews praise customer service

Lack of hidden fees

Offerings of preventative treatments

Services Offered

Cockroaches
Wildlife
Mice
Moths
Flies
Ants
Green pest control
Termites
Mosquitos
Silverfish
Bed bugs
Ticks
Wasps
Prevention
Spiders
General pest control

Orkin

Orkin Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
75 Nassau Terminal Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040 (917) 717-7159 orkin.com

Positive customer service reviews

Transparent pricing

Educational web content

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

General pest control
Fumigation
Prevention
Bees
Cockroaches
Wasps
Termites
Spiders
Mosquitos
Flies
Ticks
Bed bugs
Silverfish
Baiting
Beetles
Mice
Wildlife
Ants

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc.

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1512 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (516) 537-9436 arrowexterminating.com

No-cost inspections

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Reviews praise customer service

Timeliness of service

Proactive solutions for pest control

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Flies
Ticks
Bees
Prevention
Bed bugs
Fleas
Wildlife
Mice
Ants
General pest control
Wasps
Mosquitos
Cockroaches
Beetles
Termites
Spiders

Suburban Exterminating

Suburban Exterminating Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
879 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787 (631) 864-6900 suburbanexterminating.com

No-cost inspections

Positive customer service reviews

Timeliness of service

Educational web content

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Bed bugs
Termites
Fleas
Ants
Mosquitos
Wildlife
General pest control
Beetles
Cockroaches
Mice
Green pest control
Prevention
Wasps
Bees
Ticks
Flies
Spiders

EcoTech Pest Control Inc.

EcoTech Pest Control Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
650 Montauk Hwy #15, Bayport, NY 11705 (631) 868-7023 ecotechli.com

Free inspections

Reviews praise customer service

Commitment to customer education

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Green pest control
General pest control
Bed bugs
Flies
Cockroaches
Baiting
Spiders
Termites
Garden protection
Wasps
Ants
Bees
Wildlife
Moths
Mice
Fleas

Fox Pest Control - Long Island

Fox Pest Control - Long Island Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
66 S 2nd St Unit D, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (631) 206-5787 fox-pest.com

Educational web content

Free inspection policy

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Ticks
Termites
Bees
Prevention
Bed bugs
Mice
Wasps
Ants
Cockroaches
General pest control
Spiders
Fleas
Silverfish
Mosquitos
Beetles

JP McHale Pest Management

JP McHale Pest Management Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
30 Pond Rd, Oakdale, NY 11769 (631) 287-5551 nopests.com

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Free inspection policy

Proactive solutions for pest control

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Ants
Spiders
Cockroaches
Mosquitos
Prevention
Baiting
Ticks
Mice
General pest control
Termites
Wildlife
Green pest control

The Bug Stops Here

The Bug Stops Here Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
600 Johnson Ave Suite C3, Bohemia, NY 11716 (631) 563-3900 thebugsstophere.com

Proactive solutions for pest control

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Free inspection policy

Reviews praise customer service

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Termites
Ticks
Spiders
Bed bugs
Green pest control
Cockroaches
Mice
Fleas
Wildlife
Prevention
General pest control
Wasps
Ants
Bees

proof. Pest Control

proof. Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1016 Grand Blvd Unit 1, Deer Park, NY 11729 (631) 935-0450 proofpest.com

Commitment to customer education

Free inspections

Consistently high customer service reviews

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Ants
Spiders
Bed bugs
Fleas
Green pest control
Mosquitos
Cockroaches
Garden protection
Termites
Mice
General pest control
Ticks

At Last Pest Control

At Last Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
496 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704 (631) 933-1136 atlastpestcontrol.com

No-cost inspections

Educational web content

Lack of hidden fees

Consistently high customer service reviews

Reliable appointment windows

Services Offered

Bees
Silverfish
Moths
Wasps
Mice
Ants
Bed bugs
Spiders
General pest control
Cockroaches
Green pest control
Wildlife
Termites
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on pest control companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Top Pest Control Brands in Islip

When ranking these pest control providers, we considered several factors including customer service, coverage, types of pest control treatments offered, industry experience, and more.

This is how the top companies in Islip ranked:

Terminix

Terminix has several hundred branches in more than 22 countries and has been in the pest control industry for about 100 years. With the amount of experience the company has, it’s easy to see why Terminix is one of the top companies in the country.

Terminix is most widely known for its specialty termite services, but they take care of much more than just that. Their other services include: rodents, spiders, ticks, cockroaches, mosquitoes, ants, and wildlife control such as skunks, opossums, squirrels, raccoons, and more. In addition to pest control, Terminix provides other services, like moisture control, attic insulation, mechanical exclusion, and home disinfection services.

Orkin

Founded in 1901 by a rat poison salesman named Otto, the Orkin brand has become one of the most reputable in the pest control industry. Due to its large network, Orkin can offer next-day, or sometimes even same-day, service.

Pests Orkin handles includes flies, yellow jackets, earwigs, moths, crickets, silverfish, mice, ticks, spiders, fleas, and more. Orkin’s typical pest control plan is also seasonal, so your home will be treated several times over the course of a year.

Rentokil

Rentokil is a well-known name in pest control, with branches across the world and almost a century of experience in the industry. Rentokil is the parent company of top North American pest control providers like Presto-X, J.C. Ehrlich, and Western Exterminator, which can provide tailored services.

Rentokil offers integrated pest management (IPM) services, which means your pest control expert will focus on both eliminating existing pests and preventing future infestations. The company has a satisfaction guarantee for its treatments. If you still have pest problems after service, Rentokil will visit again until the issue is resolved.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

Pest control providers aren't all equal when it comes to reputation, knowledge, and competence. It’s important to research businesses to find the right one for your specific circumstance. Here are the key factors to consider when choosing a pest control company:

Services Offered

You should look for a pest control company that specializes in treating the pest you have, like termites, bed bugs, roaches, or rodents. The company should describe how they go about treating your type of pest.

Expertise

Look for pest control companies with technicians that have certifications in pest control methods from qualified industry groups, such as the National Pest Management Association (NPMA), in addition to state licensing. Having the proper credentials indicates that the technicians have received adequate training. Also ask about ongoing educational requirements.

Experience and Reputation

Peruse reviews on Google, Yelp, and similar sites prior to scheduling a pest control appointment. Verify for yourself that the company reliably provides effective service and receives positive customer feedback. Also check the Better Business Bureau website for any complaints that have been filed. Ask whether technicians receive ongoing education on the newest and most advanced pest control treatments. When you choose a professional from our list of the top pest control in Islip, you can rest easy knowing you're hiring an expert that meets our quality and review standards.

Green Pest Control

If you prefer natural pest control methods, look for providers that advertise “green” certifications. For bigger animals such as mice or snakes, ask if a provider offers humane trapping and relocation. Bear in mind natural options may not work as well for significant infestations. If you have a moderate to serious pest problem, you may need stronger traditional treatments. No matter your approach to pest control, all pesticides that are classified as greater than minimal risk are required to be registered with the EPA.

Reservice Guarantee

Quality pest control companies typically offer service guarantees for ongoing plans. The guarantees mean the company will return and re-treat at no cost if your home still has pests after the initial visit. One-time treatments don't typically include reservice guarantees.

Questions To Ask Pest Control Companies

Once you have identified your top pest management companies, reach out to each one to ask these questions:

  • How often will you provide follow-up visits after the first treatment? Many companies provide monthly, quarterly, or yearly service programs to help stop infestations from returning.
  • What results should I reasonably anticipate after the initial and follow-up treatments? The company should set clear expectations about pest elimination timelines and benchmarks.
  • Can you give me detailed pricing information and service plan details in writing? This allows you to get an idea of pest control costs and avoid companies with unclear conditions or undisclosed fees.
  • When can you start treating my home? It's important to begin treatment ASAP before the infestation spreads.
  • What pest control methods and techniques do you use? Make sure the approaches meet your needs for typical chemical treatments versus natural options. Get details about the pesticides or chemicals that the company will use.

Take the time to thoroughly analyze pest control providers using these questions. This will help you hire the right provider to safely and successfully resolve your pest problem at a fair price.

Most Common Pests in Islip

A variety of pests like to find their way into Islip residences. Some are relatively harmless, but others can damage your home and your health. All of them can cause anxiety. To help you identify the most problematic pests, we studied various social media sites and made a list of the ones mentioned the most.

Below is a list of some of the most common pests: <Ul><Li>Beatles</Li><Li>Mosquitos</Li><Li>Ants</Li><Li>Bed Bugs</Li><Li>Bees</Li><Li>Fleas</Li></Ul>

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in Islip, NY

Our top picks for pest control companies in Islip are Orkin and Terminix. They're well-respected in the industry and help get rid of all common pests.

Hiring a pest control company and getting a professional to spray your property routinely is the best way to prevent future pest infestations. This deters insects and animals from coming inside your home.

For the most part, pest control chemicals are safe. However, they need to be handled by a professional exterminator to ensure they’re used properly. After your house has been sprayed, your exterminator will recommend staying away from your home for a certain amount of time. This is typically 2 to 4 hours, but can be up to 24 hours.

Many Islip homeowners are concerned about the cost of pest control. Monthly pest control typically costs $40 to $70 per visit. Quarterly pest control costs about $110 to $250 per visit. To figure out exactly how much it will cost for you, we recommend contacting several providers for an estimate.

If you already have a serious infestation, you should get pest control as soon as possible. However, if you’re just interested in preventative pest control, the best time of year to have a professional come spray your house is in the spring before nest and colony numbers get too high when it's warmer. However, it’s never too late for pest control. You can still spray in the summer or any other season and see effective results.

Other Islip, NY Home Services