29 Best Pest Control Companies in
Bay Shore, NY

Explore our guide to the best pest control companies in Bay Shore to find the right experts for your job.
Published by Pest Strategies Local Experts on August 3, 2022

No matter if you're dealing with a current pest problem or hoping to avoid one in the future, knowing the top pest control companies around Bay Shore can be a huge help. Depending on where you reside, you may need to use different pest control companies for different problems. The sometimes cooler temperatures in Bay Shore, with its average low of 49° F, don't necessarily protect from pests. Even during the colder months, you might find yourself facing an infestation of beetles, ants, or spiders.

While there are certain tasks around the home that you may feel ready to tackle yourself, pest elimination is a job best left to the professionals. It is important to conduct careful research and choose the right pest control company for the job in order to ensure that it is done safely and effectively. To aid you with getting the job done, we've put together a list of the top-rated pest control professionals around Bay Shore.

Our Top Pest Control Picks for Bay Shore, NY

Best Overall Value
Terminix logo
  • Services millions of homes each year
  • Covers all common pests
  • Satisfaction Guarantee
4.8
Get Quote
Get Started on Terminix.com
Best For Fast Service
Orkin logo
  • 120 years in business
  • Covers all common pests
  • Same-day service available
4.5
Get Quote
Get Started on Orkin.com
Best Local Network
Rentokil logo
  • World's largest pest control company
  • Commercial and residential treatments
  • Numerous regional brands
4.0
Get Quote
Get matched with a local pro

Terminix

Founded in 1927, Terminix has nearly 100 years of professional pest control experience. Its technicians are ready to serve customers anywhere, with over 300 locations throughout the country. The company provides eco-friendly pest control solutions for a wide range of insects, rodents, and wildlife. Its headquarters are in Memphis, Tennessee. Terminix is most widely known for its specialty termite services.

Orkin

Orkin Pest Control, a division of Rollins Corporation, is based in Atlanta, Georgia. The company has over 400 locations worldwide. It's been a leader in customer satisfaction since Otto Orkin started it in 1901. This makes it the longest-running modern pest control company ever. Orkin offers outdoor and indoor treatments for all kinds of pests, but the company's commercial division is where it stands out the most.

Rentokil

Rentokil, a British service group, is the world's largest and most widely recognized pest control company, representing hundreds of brands worldwide. In North America, the company currently owns nine, including Ehrlich, Presto-X, Western Exterminator, and Anderson Pest Solutions. Rentokil has been helping homeowners rid themselves of common pest problems for over 90 years. The company also has the biggest presence in the commercial pest management space in the country. Its North American headquarters is located in Wyomissing, Pennsylvania.

Local Pest Control Companies Near Me in Bay Shore

Suburban Exterminating
5

Suburban Exterminating is a exterminator active in Smithtown, NY. On their website, they say they treat problems including: termites, ticks, bed bugs, flies, moths, fleas, spiders, mice, bees, ants, wasps, cockroaches, rats, and beetles.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Arrives On Time
No-Cost Inspections
Won Local Awards
Helps Educate
Transparent Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.suburbanexterminating.com/
Phone: (631) 864-6900
Address: 879 W Jericho Turnpike
Smithtown, NY 11787

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc.
5

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc. is a exterminator based in Bay Shore, NY. These exterminators help with pest problems including: spiders, termites, cockroaches, beetles, wasps, ticks, bees, ants, flies, fleas, and bed bugs.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Arrives On Time
Preventative Treatments
Free Inspection
Award-Winning Service
Knowledgable and Friendly
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://arrowexterminating.com/
Phone: (516) 537-9436
Address: 1512 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Top Quality Exterminating Pest
5

Top Quality Exterminating Pest is a pest control provider serving Amityville, NY. These experts assist with pest issues including: cockroaches, bed bugs, spiders, mice, rats, flies, beetles, fleas, moths, termites, wasps, ticks, bees, and ants.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Free Inspection
Award-Winning Service
Knowledgable and Friendly
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.topqualityexterminating.com/
Phone: (631) 225-5667
Address: 55 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701

Majestic Pest Control of Melville
5

Majestic Pest Control of Melville is a pest control provider based in Melville, NY. They help with pests including: flies, bed bugs, termites, spiders, mice, bees, cockroaches, wasps, rats, fleas, mosquitos, and ants.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Preventative Services
No-Cost Inspections
Won Local Awards
Knowledgable and Friendly
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://majesticpestcontrol.com/pest-control-melville-ny/
Phone: (516) 715-2896
Address: 785 Walt Whitman Rd
Melville, NY 11747

Terminix
5

Terminix is a exterminator operating out of Ronkonkoma, NY. They remedy pest problems including: ants, cockroaches, mosquitos, fleas, wasps, moths, ticks, termites, mice, rats, bed bugs, and spiders.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Preventative Services
No-Cost Inspections
Educates Customers
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.terminix.com/exterminators/ny/ronkonkoma-2373
Phone: (631) 201-8717
Address: 200 13th Ave Unit 1A
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

EcoTech Pest Control Inc.
5

EcoTech Pest Control Inc. is a exterminator working out of Bayport, NY. On their website, they say they assist with nuisances such as: mice, moths, rats, wasps, ants, spiders, flies, bed bugs, termites, bees, fleas, and cockroaches.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Free Inspection
Won Local Awards
Helps Educate
Transparent Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.ecotechli.com/
Phone: (631) 868-7023
Address: 650 Montauk Hwy #15
Bayport, NY 11705

Select Exterminating Corporation
5.0

Select Exterminating Corporation is a pest control company serving NY 11787, NY. On their website, they say they help with pest headaches including: bees, ticks, wasps, ants, termites, spiders, bed bugs, rats, flies, mice, and fleas.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Preventative Treatments
No-Cost Inspections
Educates Customers
Upfront Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.selectexterminating.com/
Phone: (631) 360-3660
Address: Smithtown
NY 11787, NY 11787

The Bugs Stop Here
5.0

The Bugs Stop Here is a pest control provider working out of Bohemia, NY. These exterminators treat pests including: rats, fleas, mice, ants, bees, bed bugs, mosquitos, cockroaches, termites, ticks, and wasps.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Preventative Treatments
Free Inspection
Knowledgable and Friendly
Transparent Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://thebugsstophere.com/
Phone: (631) 563-3900
Address: 600 Johnson Ave Suite C3
Bohemia, NY 11716

Fox Pest Control
4.8

Fox Pest Control is a pest control provider operating from Bay Shore, NY. These experts help with pest problems including: cockroaches, mice, beetles, fleas, wasps, ticks, spiders, ants, bed bugs, rats, bees, and termites.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Educates Customers
Transparent Pricing
No-Cost Inspections
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://foxpest-longisland.com/#utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gmb
Phone: (631) 206-5787
Address: 66 S 2nd St Unit D
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Mission Exterminating
4.7

Mission Exterminating is a pest control provider working out of NY 11788, NY. On their website, they say they exterminate pests including: bees, ticks, mice, termites, mosquitos, fleas, bed bugs, wasps, and ants.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Preventative Treatments
Free Inspection
Helps Educate
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://missionexterminating.com/
Phone: (631) 449-2554
Address: Hauppauge
NY 11788, NY 11788

Terminix
5

Terminix is a pest control provider serving Plainview, NY. These experts remedy problems including: ants, mosquitos, fleas, mice, cockroaches, bed bugs, termites, rats, spiders, wasps, moths, and ticks.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Preventative Treatments
Free Inspection
Helps Educate
Transparent Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.terminix.com/exterminators/ny/plainview-2261
Phone: (516) 207-1128
Address: 45 S Service Rd
Plainview, NY 11803

National Pest Experts
4.6

National Pest Experts is a pest control provider serving Holbrook, NY. They assist with pest issues such as: wasps, cockroaches, bed bugs, beetles, fleas, termites, spiders, bees, ants, mice, and rats.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Easy to Work With
Reliable Appointment Windows
Upfront Pricing
Free Inspection
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.nationalpestexperts.com/
Phone: (888) 567-7100
Address: 1484 Broadway Ave
Holbrook, NY 11741

At Last Pest Control
4.4

At Last Pest Control is a pest control company active in West Babylon, NY. They remedy pest issues including: mice, moths, ants, bed bugs, spiders, rats, and termites.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Punctual Service
No-Cost Inspections
Educates Customers
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://atlastpestcontrol.com/
Phone: (631) 213-6509
Address: 496 Sunrise Hwy
West Babylon, NY 11704

Regal Exterminators
4.3

Regal Exterminators is a exterminator based in Nesconset, NY. They help with pest problems including: cockroaches, flies, bed bugs, fleas, termites, spiders, ants, bees, and wasps.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Helps Educate
Transparent Pricing
Free Inspection
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.regalexterminators.com/
Phone: (631) 724-4993
Address: 200 Smithtown Blvd
Nesconset, NY 11767

proof. Pest Control
4.3

proof. Pest Control is a pest control provider based in Deer Park, NY. These experts assist with pests including: cockroaches, fleas, ticks, bed bugs, spiders, ants, termites, mosquitos, and rats.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Easy to Work With
Educates Customers
No Hidden Fees
Free Inspection
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://proofpest.com/service-areas/new-york
Phone: (631) 935-0450
Address: 1016 Grand Blvd Unit 1
Deer Park, NY 11729

General Exterminating
4.6

General Exterminating is a pest control provider serving Holbrook, NY. These exterminators remedy pest headaches including: rats, bed bugs, mice, wasps, ants, flies, fleas, termites, spiders, moths, and ticks.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Helps Educate
No Hidden Fees
No-Cost Inspections
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://generalexterminating.net/
Phone: (631) 319-8840
Address: 311 Bristol Ct
Holbrook, NY 11741

National Pest Experts
4.6

National Pest Experts is a pest control company active in East Northport, NY. On their website, they say they exterminate pests including: wasps, rats, ants, mice, beetles, fleas, cockroaches, spiders, termites, bed bugs, and bees.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Easy to Work With
Punctual Service
No Hidden Fees
No-Cost Inspections
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.nationalpestexperts.com/
Phone: (631) 651-8100
Address: 24 Larkfield Rd STE 2B
East Northport, NY 11731

Deepdale Pest Control & Inspection
4.1

Deepdale Pest Control & Inspection is a pest control provider working out of Huntington, NY. They treat pest headaches such as: termites and general pest control.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Punctual Service
Preventative Treatments
No-Cost Inspections
Won Local Awards
Educates Customers
Upfront Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.deepdalepestcontrol.com/
Phone: (631) 757-1122
Address: 48 Warner Rd
Huntington, NY 11743

Mosquito Joe of South Shore Long Island NY
4.1

Mosquito Joe of South Shore Long Island NY is a exterminator active in Deer Park, NY. These experts treat problems such as: fleas, ticks, and mosquitos.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Reliable Appointment Windows
Preventative Treatments
Free Inspection
Knowledgable and Friendly
Transparent Pricing
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://southshoreny.mosquitojoe.com/
Phone: (631) 458-5910
Address: 80 W Industry Ct
Deer Park, NY 11729

JP McHale Pest Management
4.1

JP McHale Pest Management is a pest control company working out of Oakdale, NY. On their website, they say they assist with pest issues including: bed bugs, flies, spiders, ants, and beetles.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Preventative Treatments
No-Cost Inspections
Educates Customers
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://nopests.com/
Phone: (631) 287-5551
Address: 30 Pond Rd
Oakdale, NY 11769

Mosquito Squad of Long Island
4.0

Mosquito Squad of Long Island is a exterminator working out of Deer Park, NY. On their website, they say they help with pest issues such as: ticks, general pest control, and mosquitos.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Renowned Customer Service
Preventative Services
Free Inspection
Won Local Awards
Knowledgable and Friendly
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.mosquitosquad.com/long-island/
Phone: (631) 203-1252
Address: 3 Saxwood St #3c
Deer Park, NY 11729

Alternative Earthcare
4.0

Alternative Earthcare is a pest control provider working out of Bay Shore, NY. These experts remedy pest issues including: ticks, general pest control, and ants.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Easy to Work With
Reliable Appointment Windows
No-Cost Inspections
Won Local Awards
Helps Educate
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.alternativeearthcare.com/
Phone: (631) 940-9050
Address: 240 S Fehr Way
Bay Shore, NY 11706

National Pest Experts
4.6

National Pest Experts is a pest control provider serving Bethpage, NY. These exterminators assist with pest headaches such as: wasps, cockroaches, rats, fleas, spiders, mice, beetles, bees, ants, bed bugs, and termites.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Reliable Appointment Windows
Upfront Pricing
No-Cost Inspections
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: http://www.nationalpestexperts.com/
Phone: (516) 937-0200
Address: 218 Broadway
Bethpage, NY 11714

gam exterminating
4.0

gam exterminating is a exterminator serving Massapequa, NY. They exterminate pests including: bed bugs, fleas, wasps, bees, spiders, ants, beetles, mice, and rats.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Upfront Pricing
Free Inspection
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.gamexterminatingservices.com/exterminator-near-me-new-york/
Phone: (917) 920-4852
Address: 324 Clocks Blvd
Massapequa, NY 11758

Pest Terminators Inc.
3.9

Pest Terminators Inc. is a exterminator serving Melville, NY. These experts help with pest headaches including: bed bugs, mosquitos, ticks, termites, ants, and fleas.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Easy to Work With
Preventative Treatments
Educates Customers
Free Inspection
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://www.pestonix.com/
Phone: (917) 913-6062
Address: 143 Old Country Rd
Melville, NY 11747

Mosquito Joe of North Shore Long Island NY
4.3

Mosquito Joe of North Shore Long Island NY is a pest control company working out of Plainview, NY. These experts treat pest problems including: ants, mosquitos, fleas, and ticks.

Company Offers and Reputation:

Great Customer Service
Punctual Service
Preventative Treatments
No-Cost Inspections
Knowledgable and Friendly
No Hidden Fees
Get Quote
Local Terminix Expert
Website: https://northshoreny.mosquitojoe.com/
Phone: (631) 458-5810
Address: 130 Newtown Rd
Plainview, NY 11803

Best Overall Value
Terminix logo
  • Services millions of homes each year
  • Covers all common pests
  • Satisfaction Guarantee
4.8
Get Quote
Get Started on Terminix.com
Best For Fast Service
Orkin logo
  • 120 years in business
  • Covers all common pests
  • Same-day service available
4.5
Get Quote
Get Started on Orkin.com
Best Local Network
Rentokil logo
  • World's largest pest control company
  • Commercial and residential treatments
  • Numerous regional brands
4.0
Get Quote
Get matched with a local pro

Common Pests in Bay Shore

Different companies around New York are more experienced at treating different types of pests. Some companies treat one specific type of common pest, such as bed bugs or termites. Before you hire a pest control company, it is an excellent idea to make sure that they provide the particular type of services that you need. For example, one of the most common pests in Bay Shore are ticks. If you have ticks on your property or in your home, you'll want to choose an exterminator that knows the best way to remove them — especially if you have pets.

Cost of Pest Control in Bay Shore, NY

Many pest control companies provide free estimates, and the easiest way to determine how much you might pay for services is to contact the company and ask. The square footage of your house and the variety of pest you are dealing with can both affect the cost of pest control services. The number of times that the technician will need to apply treatment will also affect the cost; regular or recurring services will cost less per visit than a single visit.

Is Pest Control Safe?

Ways to stay safe during the pest control process include, but are not limited to:

Do your research and make sure you use a reputable pest control company, such as one from our list.

Keep children and pets away from treated areas until your technician tells you it is safe.

Be sure that your technician conducts a thorough inspection and treats only in the necessary areas.

Can I DIY Pest Control in Bay Shore?

Thinking about tackling the pest problem yourself? There are a handful of safety factors to keep in mind. According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), there is a list of things that a consumer can do to make sure that their home pesticide application is as safe as possible:

Always read and follow all directions and safety warnings.

Try to avoid mixing your own chemicals — purchase pre-mixed ones whenever possible.

Exclusively use chemicals that are approved for residential use.

When you are able to, make use of lower-risk pesticide delivery methods such as baits or traps, or research other low-risk pesticides that are appropriate for your area of New York and for the specific type of pest.

Make sure that all chemicals and containers are properly disposed of.

No More Pests = Happier Homes
Getting help from a certified pest expert is the best way to ensure your home is free from pests.
Match with an expert in minutes

FAQs about Bay Shore Pest Control Companies

What kinds of pests do I need to be on the lookout for in Bay Shore?

Pests that are common in Bay Shore include:

  • Beetles
  • Mosquitoes
  • Ants
  • BedBugs

What is the cost difference between one-time, recurring, and preventative pest control in Bay Shore?

In Bay Shore, a one-time pest control treatment will cost, on average, about $436. Preventative or regular pest control will run around $50 monthly. Other aspects that may affect the amount you pay are the type of infestation and the size of your home.

How do I make sure that I am choosing the most reliable pest control company in Bay Shore?

A reputable, licensed pest control company must employ at least one certified and licensed commercial pesticide applicator, who needs to maintain their own certification by completing continuing education, per the EPA. All other applicators need to be either certified themselves or licensed applicators under the direct supervisor of a certified applicator. States may have different additional requirements to maintain certification and licensing. You can request a copy of the company's license, and in Bay Shore you can verify licensure and certification by contacting the New York Department of Agriculture.

You may also request copies of all pesticide labels from the company. Pesticides need to be registered by the EPA and state Department of Agriculture, although it's important to know that these organizations do not endorse specific products or companies. Registered pesticides' labels should provide information about ingredients, safety, and proper application. Lastly, you can do research on the company to discover how many years they have been active in the industry, check out resources such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to see complaints that have been filed against the company in the past, and inquire about references from previous customers.

Why should I hire pest control professionals?

In some instances, you might be equipped to handle an infestation on your own (in that case, see our list of tips above). However, hiring local Bay Shore pest control professionals to handle your pest problem can reduce much of the expense, risk, and headache. Pest control companies are the experts at identifying the cause of the issue and know the ideal way to handle it permanently — trying to tackle the problem on your own could leave you with recurring pest problems. Additionally, hiring a professional to take care of everything means that you don't have to research, purchase, and dispose of pest control products yourself. Lastly, hiring a licensed pest control company means hiring someone who understands and adheres to safe pesticide use, which will be beneficial for the health and safety of you, your home, and your family.

Is pest control safe around children and pets?

A reputable Bay Shore pest control company will be sure to do the job in the safest way possible. The precautions that need to be taken will vary depending on the type and extent of the infestation — it is best to speak with your technician ahead of the day of service. Your technician may ask you to remove any children and pets (including fish tanks) from the area before they begin the process, and to keep them away from the area for some time afterwards. Make sure you abide by all recommendations made by your technician.

pest control technician
Ready to protect your family from pests?

Get a free quote and consultation from a top-notch Bay Shore pest control expert.